What Is The Best Roaster Oven

What are the best roaster oven in the market? Yes, they are tons and that often makes people confused. But based on real verified user’s feedback and reviews and best selling list of different marketplaces we have listed here top 10 roaster oven we listed and compiled reviews from verified purchase owners.

So, if you like to have one roaster oven hope the following feedback from real users will help you a lot.

Note that we compiled here only five star ratings and reviews.

Best roaster oven Comparison Table

Best Overall
Oster Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid | 22 Qt, Stainless Steel
Oster Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid | 22 Qt, Stainless Steel
$166.17
Editor's Choice
Proctor Silex 24-Pound Turkey Roaster Oven with Variable Temperature Control and Removable Pan, 18-Quart, Black (32200)
Proctor Silex 24-Pound Turkey Roaster Oven with Variable Temperature Control and Removable Pan, 18-Quart, Black (32200)
$99.99
Nice Pick
Nesco MWR18-14 Roaster Oven, 18 Quart, White
Nesco MWR18-14 Roaster Oven, 18 Quart, White
$87.81

Top 10 Best Roaster Oven

roaster oven
Here are the top roaster oven we picked, check their features.

1. Oster Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid | 22 Qt, Stainless Steel

Oster Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid | 22 Qt, Stainless Steel

  • Electric roaster oven accommodates turkeys up to 26 pounds
  • Self basting lid continually recirculates moisture
  • Versatile electric roaster bakes, slow cooks, roasts, and serves
  • Dimensions: 23.3 L x 15.6 W x 11.8 H inches
  • Roasting pan and rack are removable for easy cleanup

Reviews from Real Users

Valerie A. Blanke

I never write reviews but for this item I truly felt the need. It's VERY scary purchasing one of these with the intention of preparing your Thanksgiving turkey day of in it. It "claims" it can cook a 20lb turkey in two hours. It "claims" it's selfbasting and that your end result will be perfect. It "claims" it frees up oven space and less stressful. I'm here to tell you I was terrified we were going to end up with Chinese take out on Thanksgiving day but I just didn't have enough oven space to do it all - so I tried it. From this point forward I will NEVER cook a turkey in the oven again !! This little gem did EVERYTHING it "claimed" and then some!! Our turkey was praised by everyone and I can tell you it was seriously moist and cooked to perfection. It really did cook it in the two hours (I had to try and slow down because I left 4 hours not sure it was accurate). I can't wait for Christmas to put my ham in it!! Don't be scared - you won't regret this purchase!!

Cheryl G.

Best turkey I have ever cooked! It roasted a 23lb turkey in 3 hours and the skin was perfectly brown and crisp. I have very happy with this purchase.

One tip: if any part of the the turkey touches the sides, place foil between it and the roaster to prevent burning.

E.Fry

This is my 2nd attempt at roasting turkey and it was a success! I prepped the turkey as usual, rubbed spices on the skin and applied butter under the skin. I placed the turkey in the roaster oven, left it there for 2 hours and bam! Like magic, a perfectly cooked turkey appeared! The skin is surprisingly crispy too! Not sure if the self basting is sufficient to get a juicy turkey. You still need to baste as I found it a little on the dry side.

Tips: make sure to prep the turkey with the roaster oven rack under it. Rather than transferring it onto the rack after it’s been prepped and lifting it into the oven. I made that mistake and it was a pain!
Do not touch the toaster oven while in use. It’s super hot! Another tip is to leave a thermometer in the turkey. The manual states the turkey is done at 180. However some parts of the turkey were still at 160 & had to cook it a little over 2 hours for a 16.46 lb bird. One last tip, put foil on the parts of the turkey that is touching the oven. It will burn.

This is money well spent!!!

2. Proctor Silex 24-Pound Turkey Roaster Oven with Variable Temperature Control and Removable Pan, 18-Quart, Black (32200)

Proctor Silex 24-Pound Turkey Roaster Oven with Variable Temperature Control and Removable Pan, 18-Quart, Black (32200)

  • DOUBLES YOUR OVEN SPACE. This electric roaster oven has an 18 qt. capacity that’s large enough to cook a 24 lb. turkey. It’s the perfect turkey roaster or chicken roaster for the holidays, parties, or anytime you’re feeding a large crowd.
  • BAKES, ROASTS, SLOW COOKS, STEAMS & MORE: This versatile electric roaster adds extra oven space to your kitchen for baking and roasting, plus it also steams and slow cooks. The dome lid makes it perfect for keeping food warm and serving guests.
  • COOKING VERSATILITY. With one simple knob, easily adjust the temperature on the electric roaster oven from 125 to 450° F, to perfectly cook a variety of foods.
  • EASY TO CLEAN. The removable cooking pan lifts out for easy cleaning.
  • EASILY REMOVE LARGER FOODS: Remove large meats like baked ham or roasted turkey with ease using the included lift-out rack.

Reviews from Real Users

Marvolene Holloway

Easy to use, clean and I cooked a 22 lb turkey in 2 hours. !! We ate, I removed remainder of meat for freezer!! Added water to bones and slow cooked over night, put in refrigerator, great broth and the solid grease on top I use to fry with!!

Jacob

This was a huge time saver on Thanksgiving! I hosted my first Thanksgiving and made my first turkey with this roaster and it turned out perfect! It cooks in about a third the time of a conventional oven and frees that space up for casseroles.

amber Lynae

Bought this when my oven broke. Not getting a new oven at prices out there, and dont bake much so bought this roaster..bakes small batch mini loaves n kids baked Christmas cookies too. We use it for varied cooking and baking..[very versatile with removable insert!] dont miss a big oven.

3. Nesco MWR18-14 Roaster Oven, 18 Quart, White

Nesco MWR18-14 Roaster Oven, 18 Quart, White

  • 18 quart capacity
  • Removable enamel cook well
  • Cool touch handles
  • Adjustable thermostat from 200 to 450 degrees
  • Ul approved

Reviews from Real Users

Avid Reader

I bought this roaster to make my thanksgiving turkey this year. I have roasted ribs (twice), turkey, and a whole chicken... and plan on a brisket for New Year’s Day. It works GREAT. The skin on my turkey and chicken didn’t brown, but we don’t eat that anyway so I didn’t care...all my meats we deliciously moist! The only thing difficult is washing it...not because it’s hard to wash, but because it is so big. I’m very happy with this purchase!

Sheila D.

I only used this at Thanksgiving for the turkey. It worked fine. The only drawback is figuring out how to brown the skin prior to removal( maybe adjusting the lid to let some air into the unit at the end of the cooking time.) My husband used his heat gun to brown it before it was carved and it actually worked. I have a smaller Nesco roaster that is over 20 years old and I never had any problems with it so I like the brand. As far as cleaning the removable insert, due to it's size it is a bit challenging but that is to be expected. Overall I would recommend this roaster.

L Hackney

Sent it to California for Daughters first Christmas dinner ... Having a small over in her apartment. The roaster made a tremendously awesome First Turkey!!

4. AROMA 18Qt. Roaster Oven (Black)

AROMA 18Qt. Roaster Oven (Black)

Reviews from Real Users

Sandra Maddux

We used this at church and it cooked great

5. Nesco 4816-14 Porcelain Roaster Oven, 6 quart, White

Nesco 4816-14 Porcelain Roaster Oven, 6 quart, White

  • 750-Watt heating base for moist, even cooking
  • Removable 6 quart cook well serves up to 6 people
  • Full-range temperature control (200°f – 450°f)
  • Durable porcelain enamel finish
  • Stay cool side handles

Reviews from Real Users

S. Higgins

I've used and gifted this Nesco and the large one for 20+ yrs. The temperature control, easy cleaning and replaceable ceramic lined cooking well make the Nesco cookers a must have in every kitchen.
I love that the cookwell is not heavy like the crockpot slow cookers. Easy on your back!
It's versatile. Perfect for entertaining and doesn't take up alot of room on your buffet. (They look nice too!) Many times I've prepared food in my Nesco and transported it all to parties and luncheons and served warm. These are great year round. I use the Nesco year round. They're great in summer when you don't want to use your oven and heat up your house. Keeps our A/C bill down!
It cooks as well as my gas range oven. I prepare roasts,, casseroles, side dishes (Mac n Cheese, Potatoes dishes etc); all are cooked thoroughly.
I bought a new one only because my kitchen decor changed. I've bought them for college students. They love them. I gifted my daughter both the large and the 6 qt in 2000. She's still using them. The price is great because they last for decades.

Megan Hartley-Simpson

This is replacing a well loved Nesco Roaster of indeterminate age that still works, but the pan got flaky. These are just the best thing to own if you don't want a kitchen full of appliances. Very versatile. I mostly use mine as a slow cooker because I like tormenting my family for hours with incredible aromas, but it also roasts better than the oven ever could. Being able to adjust the temperature more accurately than L-M-H is important to me and Nesco makes a great product.

B. Hughes

I own the larger Nesco and I cook my turkey in it several times a year. My home has downsized so I purchased the 6qt. It’s wonderful. I cooked a casserole in it and a stew. They both came out wonderful. All the temperatures worked well. After cooking and serving the pot was easy to clean. While cooking the roast beef for the stew I seasoned it, added my ingredients and covered. I went shopping and when I came home the meat was very tender and the broth was ready to add the vegetables. I love this pot and it’s the right size fir me. I’m never disappointed with Nesco.

6. Nesco MWR18-12 Roaster Oven (Red, 18-Quart)

Nesco MWR18-12 Roaster Oven (Red, 18-Quart)

  • All In One: Roast, bake, cook, steam, slow cook and serves all in one
  • Base and Capacity: 1450 heating base, 18 quart capacity
  • Removable Cookwell: Removable cookwell with integrated side handles
  • Temperature Control: Full-range temperature control (200 degree F-450 degree F)
  • Finish: Durable porcelain enamel finish

Reviews from Real Users

norma

My friend loved this. She wrapped up a brisket in foil and put it in the roaster..it turned out so tender. She loved the color.

7. Oster Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid, 18 Quart, Black (CKSTRS18-BSB-W)

Oster Roaster Oven with Self-Basting Lid, 18 Quart, Black (CKSTRS18-BSB-W)

  • 18-quart roaster oven roasts, bakes, and slow cooks and fits up to a 22-pound turkey
  • Self-basting lid recirculates moisture for tender and delicious roasts
  • Saves 30% time and uses 36% less energy than a traditional oven
  • Removable enamel-on-steel roasting pan for fast, even heat distribution and easy cleaning
  • Variable temperature control dial to set cooking temperature from 150 to 450 degrees F

Reviews from Real Users

Kathleen Steuber

Amazon kept suggesting that I purchase this item and after seeing it pop on the side of my screen so many times, I caved in (the price was $19.99 on special.) I used it for the first time for Thanksgiving (risky, I know!) The turkey was 20lbs and just fit in the roaster. It should have taken 5.5 hours in the oven. After 3 hours I decided to peek into the roaster to see how it looked and lo and behold, the turkey was starting to fall off the bones! I put the thermometer in the breast and the turkey was done! The skin wasn't dark but no one in my family eats the skin so the aesthetics didn't really matter. we carve and plate on the turkey platter before we bring it to the table. The turkey was so moist and so delicious! I will never make another turkey in the oven again! My entire family raved over how fantastic the turkey was and how much time we saved. Also, the house wasn't sweltering from having the oven on all day long so that was a plus, too!! highly recommend this roaster!

Amazon Customer

This has been one of the best purchases that I have made in a long time. The oven does exactly what it says it can do and then some. I tested it twice with baking a cake and cupcakes in it and they came out even more moist than from the oven. I even made chicken soup in it and came out beautifully. The best one was when I cooked ribs in it. They came out moist falling apart and just perfect. It does take some getting use to with the amount of heat the oven puts out but once you figure it out its a blessing. I have used it a total of times since I ordered it before Christmas It's proven its worth to me. I am thinking of getting another so that I can have two of them around for the holidays.

Mammadoc

Got this roaster as I wanted more oven room for the holidays. Must say I was pleasantly surprised by the value of this product. Only proviso I can recommend is to closely watch time you bake as it gets really hot in there and hence cooks quickly. Loved how crispy and brown the skin on a turkey got when I used, but think I let it cook too long. Cleaned up almost unbelievably easy even with juices crusted on bottom. Will keep using to alleviate the issues I had. For this price, this is an incredible roaster and I can highly recommend.

8. Roaster Oven (KU1000) – Stainless Steel & Black, 1450W, 18 Qt

Roaster Oven (KU1000) - Stainless Steel & Black, 1450W, 18 Qt

  • Cooks up to a 22 lb turkey
  • Roast, slow cook, stew, bake and steam foods
  • The surround heat feature cooks food from the sides, not from the bottom, for moist, even results
  • High dome cover accommodates large roasts and poultry
  • Variable temperature control

9. NESCO ITR-01 Digital Infrared Upright Turkey Roaster, Oil Free, 1420 Watts, Silver

NESCO ITR-01 Digital Infrared Upright Turkey Roaster, Oil Free, 1420 Watts, Silver

  • Cooks up to an 18 lb. Turkey in 2 hours
  • Electronic Controlled Heating Elements with Preset High/Low Heat Option
  • Center Heating Element with On/Off Option for Uniform Cooking Inside and Out
  • Includes Glass Viewing Cover, Easy Grip Side Handles and removable Cooking Stand with Drip Tray for easy clean-up
  • Stainless Steel Construction and Non-Stick Interior, 1420 Watts

Reviews from Real Users

Amazon Customer

I bought this to make our turkey for Thanksgiving since my oven has been acting up and I'm so happy I did. The turkey was amazing and only took 2 hours, it was literally perfect!

goverland

Hard to believe but doing a turkey in under two hours can be done. The turkey came out crispy on the outside and oh so moist on the inside. Also made a chicken in it and roast chicken at home is much better than store bought. Not bad to clean up and the thought of having turkey anytime is so great. Will be trying a roast next.

2021 Update: still amazing to cook a turkey so quickly and it's still working

Jan

Have used this to cook a 13 lb Thanksgiving Turkey which it did in a little over 1 hour as well as rib eye roast and it worked great for both. The ability for using the central element to heat the turkey from the inside seems to be an important part of speeding up the cooking of turkey. In using this for the rib eye roast with the central element turned off, functions as a good roaster oven with cooking time similar to a convection oven it seems. There was information in the directions that came with the roaster about using it for other roast which I did not think was included from earlier feedback that I sought prior to the purchase. It is a large roaster that does take up space so be aware. I am VERY happy I purchased this roaster!

10. Chefman 14 Quart Roaster Oven Cooker w/High Dome Self-Basting Lid, Perfect for Slow Cooking, Baking, Serving & More, XL Family Size Fits 20 Lb Tur

Chefman 14 Quart Roaster Oven Cooker w/High Dome Self-Basting Lid, Perfect for Slow Cooking, Baking, Serving & More, XL Family Size Fits 20 Lb Turkey or Roast, Removable Dishwasher Saf, Black

  • Tender, flavorful food: This 14-quart roaster oven has a self-basting lid that recirculates moisture for tender, flavorful food, while the viewing window allows you to see your food as it’s roasting without opening the slow cooker. Perfect for slow cooking, roasting, steaming, baking, and serving!
  • Large capacity: the high dome lid adds more capacity for roasting large meals. It can accommodate a 20 lb turkey; lift-out rack included for large items. Perfect for weekly meal planning, family gatherings, game day, holidays, parties and large events, and more. Cooking large meals has never been this easy!
  • Faster than an oven: double your cooking efficiency with this roaster – it is 30% faster than traditional ovens and can heat up to 450F. Defrost setting is time-saving as well – Go from frozen to perfectly roasted in hours! Switch the roaster to keep warm once your dish has finished cooking to keep it warm until you are ready to eat.
  • Easy cleaning: roasting pan and lid are removable so you can hand wash them easily, stainless-steel roasting rack is dishwasher safe for effortless cleaning.
  • Resources: cetl approved with advanced safety technology for long lasting durability, & 1-year warranty provided by Chefman, so you can purchase worry-free – We’ve got your back! For information on how to use your product, scroll down for a PDF user guide.

Reviews from Real Users

Pinky Garza

Like the size ... just perfect for a good roast.. Received it on time ...it just had a small dent in the front but it will not interfere with a good meal

My confidence is slipping on your products!

Temperature control is on point. Easy to clean and manageable.

Carol D. Elmore

This was a gift for my step-daughter in Oregon, so I can’t answer your questions

What to Consider for roaster oven

Here are the key considerations

Features You are Looking for

The product should have the features you are looking for. All the reputed marketplaces and online shops write product descriptions, read them, assess them according to your need. If you are not happy with what they wrote on there, ask them.

You know what? Ifs better to regrate before than after purchasing a product online. Returning products is a hassle.

While checking the product features, compare its pros and cons. Here in our list, we picked the {replaceKey} features from Amazon, to make a quick look. Hope that helps.

Users Feedback and Brand Recognition

Certainly, a product is available on the market for a while, the brand hit some sales and obviously, there is a customer base. If you make a few google searches and read some user feedback you will get a nice idea about that product and brand value and recognition.

The good thing is here we have compiled some good feedback from real users, I mean verified product owners.

There are a few tricks to understand a brand value and recognition like how loyal the customers are, how much visible the brand is? What is their customer support like?

Support and warranty

Sometimes the product you purchase needs customer support and that’s important. So it’s better to check their official website and support system. How faster their response is and how helpful they are.

So support depends on your product type and services. You should define the product and how consistent customer support you will be needing or not.

Product Price

Product price plays an important role in purchase decisions. Yes, some products provide real value for the money, but it does not mean high price product is always good. But you know money talks and a product with better price, chances are the product is good.

Conclusion

The customer reviews compiled above helped you to understand the pros and cons of the product. Customers review helps to take decision real quick. It saves your time and effort. So you got some idea on roaster oven, That is our happiness.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published.