The following article is Part 1 of a 2-part series about taming our inner voices. Part 1 is about discovering where the inner voice has come from.
That Voice In Our Heads
Our inner voice is what decides how we live our lives. It has also been known as the ‘inner critic’, or the ‘inner judge’. Our inner voices are our own conscience telling us what we should or shouldn’t be doing, and what we can or can’t do. It’s our director in the movie of our lives.
Yet there’s a problem – the director is abusive. It often berates its cast and crew, and yells and screams whenever someone slips up and makes a mistake. And whenever this director finally leaves us alone to get on with our lives, we’re still reminded of our incompetence and inability whenever it even looks like we’re about to slip up again. The director is harsh, and has been for some time – ever since we were children.
This director has been inspired and forged by our peers – our parents who told us we needed to speak up more, or our teachers who admonished us in front of the class, or our friends who laughed at us when we fell over. Any or all of these people have had some responsibility in forming the inner voice in our heads that now controls our lives with an iron fist.
Each of us has a unique inner voice that commands no-one else but ourselves. No-one else can hear our own inner voice, and we can’t hear anyone else’s. Because of this, it’s hard for someone else to precisely understand the grief that our inner voice gives us. We may pour our hearts out when we try to explain how tough our lives are, but all the other person can do is offer advice and short-term solutions. They can give you a fish, but they can’t teach you to fish.
And why can’t they help you out? Because they can’t hear what your inner voice is saying. And if they can’t hear what that dastardly director is saying to you, then how they can help out? Whatever they can possibly do for you just won’t help in changing the tune of the inner voice.
No, that responsibility lies solely with you.
Stopping The Inner Critic
As much as the inner voice loves to come out and berate you over something that you’ve done wrong, how often do we actually stop and listen to the voice? Sure, we may kick ourselves and do exactly what the voice tells us, but can we recognise the sound of the voice?
I remember when I first stopped midway through a ‘self-bashing’. After knocking some fruit off a fruit bowl, I began to berate myself for being so clumsy, and that I should look where I’m going more often, and so on. But when I made the decision to stop listening to the voice in my head, the voice magically fell silent. I couldn’t hear the stern inner critic any longer.
Then I asked myself, why was I beating myself up this way? Nobody else was blaming me for the mistake I made, so why should I be so harsh on myself? The answer was just that, I couldn’t think of any valid reason why I was being so harsh on myself.
Then I began to feel pity, and a genuine self-love. I realised I needed to take much better care of myself. There was no need to be so stern, and it certainly wasn’t helping me in any way – I wouldn’t improve my co-ordination after a fierce telling off!
After I had calmed down, I then remembered what my inner judge had said in the moments leading up to my peace. More importantly, I remembered what my judge sounded like.
Who’s Speaking?
At first, I thought the judge sounded like me. Then I thought the judge was me, and I began to despair a little. Why am I beating myself up so much? Despite my desires to love myself, I found it was all too easy to let the inner voice take over and admonish me for any little mistake.
But I decided to dig deeper. I needed to know why I was being so harsh on myself, and why my inner voice was choosing to judge and dictate, rather than love and care. Then I realised that although my inner voice sounded a lot like my own, the words weren’t my own to begin with. They were the words of other people.
Remember earlier when I said about how our peers form and shape our inner voices? This is how – by branding our memories with their words. When they talk down to us, or judge us, or even give well-meaning advice that doesn’t sound right, their words remain with us well into our adulthoods. They play their part in forming our identity, and forming our inner voices, to the point where they decide how we view ourselves day-to-day, even if the initial incident happened many years ago.
On this occasion, my inner voice was comprised of an old school teacher who lectured me in front of the class when I knocked some paint over onto the floor. Now that I remembered the event, I could link it to the sound of my teacher’s voice incredibly easily. The tones of my teacher’s words were as clear as ever in my inner judge. I now knew why I was beating myself up – because I hadn’t let the memory of that event go.
In my mind, the teacher had been lecturing me for any little mistake I made. And this had been going on for years.
Now that I know what my inner voice is actually made up, I can more easily take steps to identify its source whenever it pops up again to have a go at me. The freedom I felt on that day when I realised the true source of my inner voice was wonderful, and I’ve always managed to retain a piece of that freedom ever since.
Part 2
In Part 2, I will be talking about how to tame that inner voice. I will talk more about the process that I used, and how I continue to use it whenever I hear the stern inner judge rise up again. More importantly, I will reveal how you can use what I learned to tackle and tame your own inner voices, so that they never have a tight grip on your lives ever again.
If you feel ready to discuss your struggles with your inner voices, please leave a comment below and I’ll be happy to help you out!
Image courtesy of Kevin Cornell






{ 40 comments… read them below or add one }
If you see graffiti on a wall, is it art? Or if the wall is on your house vandalism?
Is it what your inner voice tells you?
Mixed words on a blogg or a seed that grows into a tree of Knowlege.?
It is an inner voice that tells you of a dream? Is the outer voice that will achieve that dream?
If you don’t ask the question you can’t gain an answer.
Just keep on doing what you do best Stu.
They told me “It only takes an acorn to grow a forest”. ~ sekwoya04
Very wise words coming from a very wise man
My inner critic has been so harsh for the past few years I ended up being angry. I’ve kind of tamed him already, I don’t criticize myself to the point of depression anymore, and I feel a lot happier. But my inner critic is still there, he pops up sometimes.
Josh Sarz recently posted..Why Writers Should Ruin Their Writing
Hi Josh,
The road to completely taming the inner critic is a long one, and some people never get to the end of that road. But by your own admission, you’re progressing well, and I hope that you reach the point where the inner critic becomes an inner friend.
Thanks for commenting
Oh, yes, I have dealt with that devilish director all my life. I really started seeing its effect when I had children and that voice began to creep out and criticize them. No longer was I the only one clumsy or stupid. Since I judged myself for my inadequacies, it made those “faults” stand out in my kids. My kids really were not the problem, they were just the mirror that I was seeing myself through. You see in others what you see in yourself.
I realized that I wasn’t getting very far just stopping the behavior (of criticizing my kids) – that was tying to solve the problem backwards. I had to work on my own judge. I had to turn my own critic around and start accepting and loving myself. The better I get at this, the more the judgement of others melts away…
Thank you for the post!
Dalai Lina recently posted..5-Day Detox to Jumpstart Your Year
Hi Lina,
Thank you for sharing this – you are right when you say that we use others as mirrors through which we view ourselves. Perhaps the problem is worse when we have children, as we may have a tendency to view them as ourselves rather than the individuals that they are.
The road to loving yourself can be long, but it’s always worth it
Great article Stu, and pretty well written with a very good personal style. Actually I see it sligthly different. We have two inner voices, one like you said which acts as the director, and another one which is more our inner voice only that it’s usually overwhelmed, if the term is correct, by the other one. Think about the bad devil and the good angel speaking at everyone’s ears.
The devil has a stronger voice because as you said it has been forged by our failures, or perceived failures, in our past and if those failures were strong for us we have a link and any time we live a similar situation we hear that voice and any time is stronger. It’s that part of ourselves that we should get rid of only that any time we hear it it reinforces itself.
Also we hear it because a part of our mind is devoted to protecting us and to prevent us from making again old errors. This is not bad in itself but it’s a feature many times misused. Sometimes it’s seen as the little frightened child inside ourselves, not bad per se but somehow nocive in reality as it prevents us from doing many things and just hit us in the head when we make something wrong but never pats us on the shoulder when we make something good.
Telling it to shut up you said to the little child, or the little devil, something like I’m grown up and I know how to do things. That’s why it keeps his mouth closed now. You’ve regained the control, so to speak.
I mean the director it’s not always bad in itself but has bad effects on our life if we don’t control it.
I don’t remember if last time I was Andrea or Hypnodude, well, I’m both.
Andrea recently posted..Positivity in 2012: 10 Affirmations or Intentions for 2012
Hi Andrea/Hypnodude,
It’s a pleasure to hear from you again, and thank you for leaving such a detailed response! I see your reasoning behind the ‘two-voice’ situation, and the devil/angel analogy fits that well.
Have you ever seen or read the Lord Of The Rings trilogy? The character Gollum has a split personality where he constantly battles between ‘good’ and ‘evil’. It’s the same voice, but with different emotions. Perhaps we all have the same situation inside of us, a constant fight between our two tones of voice.
Worth pondering on
The Gollum analogy is good too Stu. In Hypnosis field we say that the mind can heal and the mind can kill. Everything that help us to better understand how our mind is and how it works is extremely useful, and this includes posts like this one. Sometimes our mind works against us, and we should understand why even if most of the times is some sort of self-punishment, sometimes it seems to work against us while in reality is just misdirected. Most of the times it’s the last case.
See you when part 2 is ready.
Andrea recently posted..Dr. Link Check Review: Free Link Checker for Broken and Bad Links
That’s very kind of you to say Andrea. I do what I can to help others help themselves, and if it works, then I’m happy.
See you next time
My inner critic and I are on much better terms now than we used to be.
During my teens and early 20s, my critic was an angry, bitter voice inside me that told me I could never do ANYTHING right. Anything good I did could – and should – have been done far better. Anything I did wrong? Well, that was just typical, wasn’t it? Couldn’t expect anything more than that from someone like me, right? My critic told me that I was going crazy – that I was too needy – that I didn’t have a right expect anything from anyone. And of course, my critic told me over and over that the abuse that had happened to me in the past, and the disordered eating patterns that followed were completely *my* fault.
I can’t point to any one time or thing or revelation that changed the relationship between my critic and me. Most likely, it was the cumulative effect of a lot of psychological work, a lot more spiritual development, and just the growing and developing and evolving that comes with time. To be fair, my awesome husband also probably played a role in it too
Whatever the reasons, my inner critic is still there, but she’s a lot less harsh than she used to be. I’ve learned to bring her in on my internal “board of advisor” meetings – to listen to what she has to say, without taking it as gospel. Sometimes, she actually has useful things to say, and if I give her space to say it, she tends to be a lot less acerbic with her comments.
Great post Stuart – I’m looking forward to reading Part 2 next week!
Blessings – TANJA
Tanja @ Crystal Clarity recently posted..Announcing… Crystal Clear Musings (my new monthly newsletter)
Hi Tanja,
I’m so happy that you’ve been able to calm your harsh inner critic! When the inner voice is raging and seemingly tyrannical, it feels like there’s nothing we can do to escape. But we can escape, it just takes time, patience, and awareness to do so. And a loving partner
Also, by accepting your inner critic onto your ‘board’, you’ve accepted that she is worth something. Not as a tyrant, but as one voice amongst many to consider. I respect you for that Tanja.
Take care
I really like that you emphasise listening to the voice and getting to know it.
Looking forward to Part 2
Evan recently posted..Welcome to the New Year from Evan
Hi Evan,
I’m glad you enjoyed the post! Hope to see you again
Hi Stu,
It’s interesting that you’re talking about this when I’ve just published a post on worry! It’s true that you can’t fight the devil you can’t see. Awareness is such a huge part of the equation! What do you do when you know who the devil is? And how does one become predisposed to accepting the criticism of peers? It has to start somewhere early in childhood, I think. I’m looking forward to reading what you say in Part 2.
Lori
Lori Gosselin recently posted..Do You Worry?
Hi Lori,
Amazing how synchronicity works in the blogging world isn’t it?
You’re right, we can’t fight an invisible enemy. If we don’t see where the problem is, we can’t make the effort to fix it. Awareness is key.
Thanks for stopping by my friend, hope all is well!
Hi Stu,
I would love it if you would stop over at my place sometime and check out the archive, as I’ve written extensively on this subject. That’s your Ego that you’re fighting with in there
It is loud and critical and undermining. However there’s the Intuition part that you have going on in there too – that’s the kind one, who leaves a space in the quiet for your higher guidance to sneak on in and change your life in a positive and kind way. Meditation is the usual way to “hear” the quiet. Simple deep breathing can also help you get there. Breathe in for 4, hold for 4, and out for 8 and observe the thoughts…when they come, send them away on a thought bubble, just imagine the criticism, to do lists, and whatever else might be rolling around in there, dissipating. That is the way you gain control of your own mind and become an Observer of your own self.
Julie | A Clear Sign recently posted..The Puzzle Of Synchronicity And Setting Personal Boundaries
Hi Julie,
I must check out your archives, as it sounds like you have an extensive knowledge of this topic!
Thank you for sharing your tips too, they sound like they would work well. Regular practice of these would mean the inner critic would calm down, and the voice would quieten.
Take care
I read about your blog through Danny Brown’s blog and just read this post. I really enjoyed it and will subscribe to your blog.
Thank you.
Patti
Hi Patti,
Thank you for coming over from Danny’s post! A pleasure to see you, and it’s a pleasure that you come from such a wonderful blog
Hey Stu,
I fought that devilish little voice in my head for many, many years. In fact the little guy had so much influenc, he stopped me from doing just about everything. Fear, worry, trepidation set in, but it was mostly that voice that fed on past failures, past embarrassments, perceived inadequacies. Regardless, that terrible voice can haunt us. It sure beat me up for years.
Quieting that voice is work, but yes it’s all about awareness, and working to change your perception, your outlook each and every day. Just getting out and embracing discomfort has been my best tool for growth.
Thanks, Stu!
Craig McBreen recently posted..I need some advice, now!
Hi Craig,
It sounds like you are in a much better place now than where you were before, and that’s heartening to hear. Our inner voices can run amok and place a stranglehold on our logical thoughts and actions, never letting us get a moment’s peace. The world can be so cruel at times that we buckle under the pressure of the negative voices, and our inner critic takes over.
Embracing discomfort is one of the best ways to help us return to a healthier place. The more we do it, the less discomfort there is in the world.
Thanks for stopping by my friend
Hey Stuart,
I had a bad inner voice too and it created a lot of trouble! Stopped me doing anything right; or doing anything at all! But basically, the inner critic is just stemming from feelings of insecurity, inferiority, past failures and the likes.
The fact remains that once we fail failure, instead of learning from them, we tend to “store” them up in some part of the head and tend to feed on them when something new or challenging comes along.
Waiting for part 2!
Hi Hajra,
We’re in the same boat with past experiences of harsh inner voices! They feed on what we perceived went wrong in our pasts, and use that to influence and direct the present.
But here’s the thing – the more we view past events as ‘bad’, the more fuel the inner critic has. On the flip side, the more we view past events as ‘good’, the less fuel the harsh inner critic has. Then the voice quietens, and we gain a new voice of peace and calm.
Take care Hajra
Great post, Stu, and I’m not surprised. I know this connects to many (as seen by your comments already
).
My personal take on it is this.
There are millions of external voices telling us things since we’re born. Some of them though they started externally, we’ve heard so much, we’ve turned them into habits and mantras we repeat on auto-pilot, internally.
There’s only one truly inner-voice though, and it comes from within and it *feels* different. It may match up with other voices or it may speak something opposite, and it may change it’s mind from moment to moment, but whatever the case, it is ‘natural’, and to be followed.
(I talk about this here: http://ryzeonline.com/the-tools-of-happiness-thoughts-feelings-and-focus )
My 2 cents
Great post, looking forward to part 2.
Jason Fonceca recently posted..Ryze Success Steps – Kinetic Typography
Hi Jason,
Thanks for stopping by and sharing your thoughts – I’m interested by your take on this topic, and I’ll be heading over to your post to find out more.
Take care my friend
Love to connect Stu! Thank you!
Basically my take is that every animal (and if you want to get deep… ‘thing’) has a ‘natural instinct’ or ‘calling’ and it guides them always, whether they’re listening to it, or to millions of external ‘stuff’.
Jason Fonceca recently posted..How Bad Do You Want It? [Intense Desire!]
That’s a very interesting take on the natural world (including humans) Jason, one which we could talk about for hours on end!
The ‘natural instinct’ that you refer to – do you think it’s something that we have from birth and are ‘stuck with’ for the rest of our lives, or do you think it can be molded and re-shaped over time by our external situations?
This is a brilliant post Stuart. I like to think of my inner space as a house. If other people want to talk in my house then they better pay some rent. Because they certainly can’t do it rent free!
Hi Hiten,
That’s a wonderful way to look at it – your house is your own, and so you can set your own rules!
Thanks for commenting
Stu, I am looking forward to the rest of this series. I wish I had written it, to be honest, because it’s brilliant. And we all need a reminder of it. Before you even got there, I was thinking, “it’s the voice of others.”
What I’ve found as well is that it doesn’t even HAVE to be the voice of others, just the FEAR of the voice from others based on one or two bad experiences. How many times have we let the fear of what “They” would say IF… only “they” haven’t actually said anything.
Great talk, man. Can’t wait to see the rest.
Bryan recently posted..How Running Can Be the Cheapest Therapy Ever
Hi Bryan,
That’s a great addition to the conversation – it can also be the fear of what others ‘might’ say, rather than what they actually say. They may not say anything at all, but the fear of the potential negativity is enough to send our inner voices into overdrive.
Hope to see you again my friend
Great thoughts Stu,
I liked the post mainly because you discussed the topic at a very granular level.
If you dig further deeper, it’s the inner critic which spontaneously responds to any of our decisions (whether the reply is positive or negative). Then, our heart either controls it or succumbs to it.
The inner critic is powerful, instant and brainy. But not all decisions are taken using the brain. If that was the case, the world would have missed so many passionate achievers who followed their hearts by taming their inner critics
You have given me food for thought to kick start the new year.
Naveen Kulkarni recently posted..What Horrible Things You Have Been Taught That Stop Success
Hi Naveen,
I like your take on this – the heart can take the lead over the brain. Once that happens, although we must be careful not to be too emotional, we can live our lives with a lessened fear of what others might think. We can live more on our own terms.
Thanks for commenting
I think our inner critic is there to protect us but often ends up doing more harm than good. It frequently lacks perspective and a sense of humor.
Hi Maria,
It lacks a sense of humour because that would class as fun, and as fun is ‘good’, the inner voice wants no part of it
As humorless as the critic is, I have found it to be an equal opportunity underminer. If fun is called for, it will be a wet blanket, if serious is called for it will be pessimistic and cynical. I think it likes to have the last word.
It sure does Maria, the inner-voice wishes to remain in control and dominate your thinking and actions. If you find that you are berating yourself, then the inner critic is in command.
Hello I’m new to your blog and so far like it very much.
I find that I have a positive and negative inner voice. Sometimes other people’s opinions affect me and the way I think of myself. For example I think I am doing something well and then someone criticizes something I did, I begin to loose confidence in myself and I than start making even more mistakes because I become self-conscious and start loosing my confidence.
But I just stop myself from listening to that negative inner voice and focus on the positive one, because that’s the best I can do for myself.
I also feel that there is a voice in us which tells us what we should be doing and we know that what it’s telling us is true, but we are scared to listen to it, because it involves us leaving our comfort zone – the biggest challenge is to really have the courage and to act on that inner voice, because as someone said, one day we will regret the things we haven’t done, and not the ones we did do.
Maia recently posted..Achieving your goals in 2012
Hi Maia,
It sounds like you have a healthy perspective on the ‘big picture’ of life, well done to you! It’s a shame when someone else actually criticises us, but we must look at why they are doing so. Are they trying to help us by offering us advice, or are they venting their own insecurities by trying to harm others? A greater awareness is key to greater understanding.
Thanks for commenting
{ 2 trackbacks }